I think this is may be like trying to say who makes the better burger: McDonald's or Burger King. To elaborate on that point:
1) XP has at least 4 different versions: Home, Media Center Edition, Pro and 64-bit version. Which of the 4 are you meaning? Any of them or all of them?
2) Vista has 12 versions as there are the 3 consumer versions, 2 business versions and the emerging markets as well as both a 32 bit and 64 bit version of each I think. Which do you mean here?
This is without considering other factors like costs and familiarity. After having used XP for as long as I have now, how much pain will I have to learn how to use Vista? While some things may "look cool," how much of a problem will I have troubleshooting when things don't work like they should?
There are arguements to be made for each side and right now I'd say I'm biased toward XP though that is subject to change if one wants to bribe me. :twisted:
Home Desktop: VoodooPC Hexx. AMD Athlon FX-60, 2 GB RAM, 2 x 250 GB HD, 7900 GTX video card.
Home Laptop: HP dv4000, Pentium M, 2 GB RAM, 80 GB HD, ATi 700 Radeon Mobility