Quantcast
PC World
You are not logged in, click here to log in.
6 Replies Last post: Aug 17, 2007 8:43 AM by smax013  
Click to view Jonah's profile New Member 3 posts since
Aug 16, 2007
Reply

Aug 16, 2007 12:11 AM

Line art - laser or inkjet?

I need a printer to produce zines and other booklets with line images, on plain paper or uncoated art paper. The priority is that the images be razor-sharp, and that black is printed a true, deep black. If possible, archival-quality ink would be an advantage. I will use colour only occasionally.
Will a laser printer suit me better than an inkjet? If so, any suggestions?
Reply
Click to view rgreen4's profile Member Moderators 4,197 posts since
Oct 22, 2006
1. Aug 16, 2007 8:29 AM in response to: Jonah
Line Art
A couple of points that you have to consider. You mentioned uncoated art paper. If I'm not mistaken, that would have a fairly course texture and is absorbant. Using an inkjet would have a tendency to blur.

The tighter the finish, the sharper an inkjet would be. However, coated paper would slow down the drying and it would be subjet to smearing.

Laserjets do not use ink, but use toner. Again, the smoother and tighter the finish, sharper a laserjet would be. However, if the uncoated art paper is course in texture, then the laserjet image would tend to have small skips.

Up until 20 years ago, fine linen business letterhead paper was course and had a texture to it. The more the texture, the finer the paper. Impact printers and typewriters were unaffected since they pushed down the texture when the text was put on the paper, and the texture would rebound afterward.

With the advent of lasers, the fine business letterhead paper has become smoother with less and less texture - because of the laser images.


RGreensig2B
Click to view rgreen4's profile Member Moderators 4,197 posts since
Oct 22, 2006
3. Aug 17, 2007 12:36 AM in response to: Jonah
Line Art
Take an image, put it on disc, find some friends who have some of the various types and try them.


RGreensig2B
Click to view smax013's profile Old Hand 3,860 posts since
Jan 28, 2007
4. Aug 17, 2007 4:56 AM in response to: Jonah
Jonah wrote:Thanks for your reply - that's useful to keep in mind.

The kind of art papers I'm thinking of using are very smooth, though, having been put through a hot press. They're not the rougher-textured cold press papers.

But even for plain, photocopy paper I'm confused about whether lasers or inkjets are better at reproducing line art.

With inkjets, it can REALLY depend on the paper. Some papers will cause ink to "wick" and thus blur...some won't. "Plain, photocopy" paper can still mean quite a few different things.

Laser printers are a little less picky, but the paper can still make a difference from my experience.

I would second rgreen's suggestion. Get some paper that you believe that you would use and then see if you can find some printers to test it on...if it is that important.


[soapbox] Backup good...no backup bad!! [/soap box]
Click to view smax013's profile Old Hand 3,860 posts since
Jan 28, 2007
6. Aug 17, 2007 8:43 AM in response to: Jonah
Jonah wrote:Thank you both for your replies - I will do as you suggest and try out the papers in some machines - perhaps I will see if a store will allow me to test some samples in various printers before I buy.


But can anyone recommend a particular model of laser printer for printing graphics and line art? The reviews of inkjet printers all discuss their image quality, but most reviews of laser printers focus on text quality and printing speed, and hardly mention graphics at all.


It has been a LONG time since I remember seeing a review in one of my main stream computer magazines talk about print quality (either in text or graphics) in great detail. Frankly, I have been less than impressed with many of the "review" or comparison articles that come in current mainstream computer magazines.

You might see if you can find a magazine that caters to desktop publishers and/or graphic artists and see if they have some reviews.

Beyond that, I am not much help on print quality. A page from one laser printer looks much the same to any other laser printer to me...and I doubt it would matter too much even if I could notice some difference. :D


[soapbox] Backup good...no backup bad!! [/soap box]

Visit other IDG sites: