Quantcast
PC World
You are not logged in, click here to log in.
217 Replies Last post: Jul 1, 2008 4:17 PM by esklsnrq   Go to original post 1 ... 9 10 11 12 13 ... 15 Previous Next
Click to view JimmyDahGeek's profile New Member 30 posts since
Dec 6, 2007
150. Dec 28, 2007 5:47 AM in response to: rgreen4
Re: Farewell Vista, Hello XP

but would not ead any NTFS drive, nor read the NAS device with all my files

In less than 5 minutes I Googled "read a NTSF drive with Ubuntu" and the first hit was https://help.ubuntu.com/community/MoutingWindowsPartitions

  • Click ApplicationsSystem ToolsNTFS Configuration Tool
  • The upcoming tool will detect NTFS partitions on
    your system. Check each partition you wish to access, and, if you wish
    to, click the mount directory to change it. When finished, click Apply.
  • On the next screen Enable write support for internal device will be selected by default. Click OK.

This doesn't look like an arcane text based fix. It almost looks like a Windows solution. <g>

Click to view rgreen4's profile Old Hand 3,442 posts since
Oct 22, 2006
151. Dec 28, 2007 8:20 AM in response to: JimmyDahGeek
Re: Farewell Vista, Hello XP

Out of curiousity, I tried your link and got this:

Capture1.JPG

Then when I tried the link to MountingWindowsPartitions/ThirdPartyNTFS3G there were instructions for 6.06, 6.10 and 7.04 with the last commentary over 6 months old. Nothing about 7.10 and this is the introduction:

Capture2.JPG

Following the headings for the three types of Ubuntu are text based commands. You may not call them arcane, but the terminology is foreign to anyone not versed in Linux.

Most of the NTFS volumes I would have been interested in accessing are not on the systems in question, but other systems on the network and the Network Attached Storage where all my data resides. It is a moot point anyway, since I have had my dabble in Ubuntu and went back to XP and Vista which work for me.

Jackie40d - when you live out in the country as I do, Sprint and Verizon are not even on the map. My telephone provider is Windstream and although I can see the main box from my front yard they have not deemed to install the $30,000 card to enable DSL in this area. I have good cell phone service from AT&T because I am on a few miles west of I75, but 5 miles west of here we loose cellphone service until we get close to Thomasville. Starbucks in either 30 miles north in Tifton, or 22 miles south in Valdosta. On Hughesnet standard service the daily limit is 200MB and then it goes on restriction (slower than dial-up) for the remainder of the 24hours. We do have unlimited download from 3AM to 6AM but the download speed is only "up to" 750kbps. And that's at the bargain price of $60 a month! Not everyone lives in a metro area with high speed choices.


Photobucket Photobucket Photobucket
Click to view JimmyDahGeek's profile New Member 30 posts since
Dec 6, 2007
152. Dec 28, 2007 9:23 AM in response to: rgreen4
Re: Farewell Vista, Hello XP
Sorry I had a typo in the url. try https://help.ubuntu.com/community/MountingWindowsPartitions. I have not tried attaching to a NAS, but I'm sure it can't be that difficult.
Click to view rodent042's profile New Member 17 posts since
Dec 9, 2007
153. Dec 28, 2007 9:47 AM in response to: rgreen4
Re: Farewell Vista, Hello XP

"Perhaps I should have said my time with a lack of frustration and
aggrivation is worth more that that. I spent more time trying to get
Ubuntu installed and communicating on one machine that I have spent on
Vista getting it installed and functional on all three machines
combined."


Perhaps you should have. This is an honest and real reason. Thank you! There is undoubtedly a learning curve with linux and plenty of people don't want to take the time. I can completely understand that. I have no doubt that someday there WILL be a viable alternative but it is not ready for everyone just yet.

I, for one, am glad that there are choices. If any one company over history had managed to crush all competition, be it Apple, Amiga, Microsoft, Sun, Tandy (God help us!), whomever, we would never have seen the advances we have today.

btw, wanna talk about ugly learning curves from the past? I have one word.... edlin (shudder) I never did get the full hang of it without a cheat-sheet :P

Click to view rgreen4's profile Old Hand 3,442 posts since
Oct 22, 2006
154. Dec 28, 2007 10:04 AM in response to: rodent042
Re: Farewell Vista, Hello XP

Your not the only one. I had completely forgotten about edlin. I had to look it up on wikipedia.

Thanks for reviving the nightmare! :^0


Photobucket Photobucket Photobucket
Click to view RedRat's profile New Member 45 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
155. Dec 28, 2007 11:44 AM in response to: Jackie40d
Re: Farewell Vista, Hello XP
Reading these various blogs concerning the ease or difficulty with Linux are probably legitimate critiques of the system. One must keep in mind that most people here are long time Windows or Mac users who are switching over to another new and different operating system. Most have spent probably 10 years dealing with the Windows or Mac interface and have learned to do things the "Microsoft Way" or the "Apple Way". Old habit die hard.

That being said, if you are thinking of switching to Linux you must realize that it is different! You must expect that there will be a learning curve, it is going to take time. If you think that you cannot "afford" to spend several hours or days reading about Linux, then please, don't attempt to change over to Linux--stay with Windows or Mac. Think carefully about why you want to switch. There are several very good books out about Linux, I would suggest that you read those before switching and certainly go online and check out the various distros of Linux before choosing the one that you like best. For practical purposes, the basic core of Linux is the same for all distros and the differences are merely "window dressing". The one distro that seems to be geared for the first timer appears to be Ubuntu, and here you have several window dressings (quite literally): Gnome and KDE (kbunuto distro). Kbuntu probably appeals to Windows users, Gnome comes with the Ubuntu distro.

Which ever distro you choose will require effort on your part. If you are looking for a simple hand holding for the installation, then stick with Mac or Windows. Both Microsoft and Apple have spent billions on making their operating systems easy to install and use.

One warning I would give in looking for help on the Linux forums and user groups (Usenet) is that there seems to be several different types of people who seem to be willing to "help". There are those who are basically anti-social geeks who know it all are superior to you, and they want to let you and the rest of the community know it also. Sad to say you just have to put up with these people and learn to ignore them. They usually do not offer any real or significant help, just insults. There are the basic geeks who think you are just as knowledgeable as they are so they tend to use acronyms and basically their help sounds like Greek. They are well intentioned but really don't know how to pass their knowledge on to you, you may get a tidbit from them that might be helpful. Then there are the users who are both knowledgeable and recognize that they too were in the same boat you are in. They will provide the most help to you. Just be patient and wade through the rif and raf and chatter, you will get there.
Click to view rgreen4's profile Old Hand 3,442 posts since
Oct 22, 2006
156. Dec 28, 2007 12:35 PM in response to: RedRat
Re: Farewell Vista, Hello XP

That is probably the best discourse I have seen on delving into Linux. Have you considered turning that into a document and posting it in the Linux discussion area?

I attempted to shorten the learning curve by purchasing the book with all the disks, but the book really didn't delve too much into explanations or teaching the differences. It probably didn't help that it was version 7.04 v 7.10.

RedRat wrote:
One warning I would give in looking for help on the Linux forums and user groups (Usenet) is that there seems to be several different types of people who seem to be willing to "help". There are those who are basically anti-social geeks who know it all are superior to you, and they want to let you and the rest of the community know it also. Sad to say you just have to put up with these people and learn to ignore them. They usually do not offer any real or significant help, just insults. There are the basic geeks who think you are just as knowledgeable as they are so they tend to use acronyms and basically their help sounds like Greek. They are well intentioned but really don't know how to pass their knowledge on to you, you may get a tidbit from them that might be helpful. Then there are the users who are both knowledgeable and recognize that they too were in the same boat you are in. They will provide the most help to you. Just be patient and wade through the rif and raf and chatter, you will get there.
I don't think the Linux users have a monopoly here. Many "help" sites in Windows suscribe to that model as well. I think that one of the things about the PC World site that makes it so great is that most of us take the latter attitude. As mph is fond of saying - we were all newbies once.

I guess one thing that has helped in this regard is that for years my late sister would call for help. Stepping back and explaining to her over the telephone (she lived 750 miles away), helped me in answering questions here, but it is much more difficult, you don't know how much they know and you have to wait for a written response.

The mistake I may have made is instead of going to the Linux thread here, I went to the Linux forum, and like others starting out, probably got ignored. I note also that there are a lot of Mac postings on this community instead of their own site. Maybe they feel more comfortable over here, and I know we have several who delve into Mac's as well as Windows machines. After all they are all - personal computers.





Photobucket Photobucket Photobucket
Click to view rodent042's profile New Member 17 posts since
Dec 9, 2007
157. Dec 28, 2007 1:05 PM in response to: RedRat
Re: Farewell Vista, Hello XP
Well said, RedRat!

Rgreen, you make a valid statement as well. Anyone who has ever tried asking advice from a hardcore MCSE has fallen victim to the "Are you stupid?" glare. "You don't know about forests and trees? DUH!"

My first support job ever was for a mid-size company (around 500 employees) who's one man "network admin/support/pc tech" guru had all of the social skills of a sheet of plywood. I was quite literally hired because people hated him and would rather muddle through their jobs than ask him for assistance. They exist somewhere in every office and forum.

Click to view RedRat's profile New Member 45 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
158. Dec 28, 2007 12:51 PM in response to: rgreen4
Re: Farewell Vista, Hello XP
Actually no I had not thought about that. To be truthful, I thought my comments here were apropos with this current thread. I don't consider myself an experienced Linux user, barely out of the newbie state would be more accurate I guess. I too have had to hit forums and usenet groups (mostly alt.os.linux.ubuntu and alt.os.linux.pclinuxos) and the Ubuntu forums. I have found that the forums are helpful but then you do have to wait for a reply since I think people pop in and then pop out. The usenet community seems a bit faster but that is where you run into the knowitalls and you will suffer through the insults. The good thing about the usenet groups is that you can usually use your newsreader to "plonk" them so it just ignores their replies or comments. But I have found helpful comments there, but you do have to pick and choose through a lot of chatter.

Yes I know that books are hard to come by with the continuous updating of Ubuntu. These updates come at 6 month intervals, the next one is due in April of next year (it will be 8.04). Because of writing and printing schedules, it would be practically impossible to have a book and release version coincide. But most of these releases are evolutionary rather than revolutionary. I think the most significant change that has come was the release of the 2007 versions. I suspect that next years versions will be mostly tweaking and improvements in the interface. I have not gotten as far as being a beta tester yet. I do believe there is a book out covering 7.04 though.

Thanks for your comments. I write here really based on my own experiences with computers that covers the past 25 years or so.
Click to view rgreen4's profile Old Hand 3,442 posts since
Oct 22, 2006
159. Dec 28, 2007 1:14 PM in response to: RedRat
Re: Farewell Vista, Hello XP
The book I got was Ubuntu for Non-Geeks, 2nd edition by Rickford Grant. As I said, he was not real long on explanations. It is a little over 300 pages long. I guess I was looking for something more, his network wireless connection explanation was to insert the wireless adapter into the laptop and let it connect. It was about a half a page with no trouble shooting help. It was also on 7.04.

Sometimes those just recently into something may be the best in writing something for others just getting into it, for they remember what it was like. I think I fell into answering the Vista questions because I had just gotten mine upgraded, and I had the book Windows Vista:The Missing Manual by David Pogue. I also have his books of similar titles on Win2K, XP and XP SP2. The Vista book is over 800 pages. I was answering question with the book open and experimenting on my Vista Machine.

After answering a question yesterday on networks, and after encouragement, I wrote a document on networks, and yet a little over a year ago, I couldn't get mine to work. I did have help and a submission from MPH on security which I added (with credit to him of course). If you put the document out there, you may get some other Ubuntu adherants to assist with their suggestions.


Photobucket Photobucket Photobucket
Click to view RedRat's profile New Member 45 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
160. Dec 28, 2007 2:06 PM in response to: rgreen4
Re: Farewell Vista, Hello XP
rgreen4,
Thanks for your encouragement. If you think it might help I would be glad to post it. Since I am new here myself (I just joined a couple of weeks ago) and have not quite felt my way around this forum, where would it best fit? If you could point me to a location I will look it over and see what to do.

Having used both Windows, Macs (got started with the little Mac SE way, way back when), Linux (in the Red Hat early days than fell away), and now modern Linux, I think my perspective is somewhat open minded (at least I would like to believe that) in regard to choice of OS. I have seen all to frequently the "true believers" for all operating systems, be they Macs (they tend to be the worst), Windows, and Unix in all of its flavors including Linux. Each of these systems has something to offer to the general public, depending on what they want to do. And that is the reason for my comments here.
Click to view mphenterprises's profile Member Moderators 8,757 posts since
Feb 19, 2007
161. Dec 28, 2007 2:59 PM in response to: PCWorld
Re: Farewell Vista, Hello XP
PCWorld wrote:
Post your comments for Farewell Vista, Hello XP here


Hi All. It is good to see such spirited discussions on Linux; however, please let's try to revert focus back onto the article.


This is my personal Dream PC: http://forums.pcworld.com/blogs/mphenterprises/2007/12/21/my-gift-to-myself
Click to view fmorriso's profile New Member 7 posts since
Dec 18, 2007
162. Dec 28, 2007 3:15 PM in response to: mphenterprises
Re: Farewell Vista, Hello XP

Good point. Is anybody in the 'farewell' camp thinking of giving Vista another try when Service Pack 1 comes out in early 2008? I have a feeling that the answer will depend on how comfortable people are with putting such a (probably huge) patch on their machine coupled with whether they installed/upgraded Vista themselves or if Vista was pre-installed by the vendor they purchased the machine from.

One thing I've started doing more often under Vista is setting older programs 'Compatibility' (a tab in the Properties window) by setting the 'run this program in compatibility mode for:' checkbox and then choosing 'Windows XP (Service Pack 2)' from the dropdown listbox of choices. Too bad Microsoft doesn't have a tool that will sift through the shortcuts in the 'Start/Programs' list as well as any desktop shortcuts and suggest which ones should probably be run in 'XP-mode' for the 'best customer experience'.

(OK, I baited the hook. Now time to sit back and enjoy the responses. :x)

Click to view Lima's profile New Member 1 posts since
Feb 26, 2007
163. Dec 28, 2007 9:34 PM in response to: PCWorld
Farewell Vista, Hello XP
WAIT a minute ok Want the best of both i don't normally comment but your readers are losin out on Vista I just read one other PC World article sayin well it's not all that bad .For the one's that want all those apps they cant run in vista I dual booted from this link http://www.apcstart.com/5485/dualbooting_vista_and_xp and let me tell you it was easier then what you went through and now i choose vista or xp depending what i want to do like download in the old morpheus or burn dvdrip movies in older nero you name it i can do it and i'm no I.T. tech or nothen just a guy that works at randalls
Click to view rkinne01's profile Member 166 posts since
Nov 29, 2006
164. Dec 29, 2007 1:04 AM in response to: rgreen4
Re: Farewell Vista, Hello XP

I agree with Red Hat and Rgreen, but I'd like to throw a fourth type into the mix. The fourth type are those who favor an opposing OS who post just rile others, it's done on the Windows boards, Mac boards, and even on the Linux boards. I don't have a problem with others using OS-X or Ubuntu, I happen to prefer Vista but if you like something else thats great. I don't think people who use Macs should be bombarded with attacks from Windows users, nor should Linux users have to deal with upitty Mac fans. I tried Unbuntu Fiesty Fawn, while I can see the potential of the OS, at this point it wasn't what I was looking for in a OS. One of the troubles I had was finding one place to get up to date info, I often had to visit several sites till I found accurate information. The layout of Ubuntu was very nice and easy to find my way around, with a setup that was just as easy as Vista's.

I would love to try a Mac OS, but won't until they allow users to install the software on any machine. I think that if Apple had done this right from the start, they would be the "evil empire' and not Microsoft, thier loss I guess. At least with Vista, Xp or Ubuntu you can install the OS's on a wide variety of machines and not just what Apple says you can.

Finally, as different as all these OS's are, they are really not that much different are they? When working with Ubuntu I wasn't totally lost, I found things quickly enough, most of the differences were minor. Just my opinion.