Quantcast
PC World
You are not logged in, click here to log in.

This Question is Answered

1 "correct" answer available (4 pts) 1 "helpful" answer available (2 pts)
15 Replies Last post: Feb 9, 2008 11:07 AM by doublewitt   1 2 Previous Next
Click to view doublewitt's profile New Member 21 posts since
Mar 29, 2007
Reply

Feb 5, 2008 3:56 PM

How does the iolo suite stand amidst the others?

Currently, I'm using the *latest from iolo technologies for security and system maintenance. So far, I have no real complaints - but - I was just wondering where does the iolo suite stand compared to others. The reason I ask is I have to renew soon with them but I'm wondering if I should make a switch to another suite. iolo includes the anti-virus, firewall, spyware detection, and complete system maintenance as well. There is really a great number of tools in this suite. But my concern is mainly SAFETY. And so does iolo have a good standing vs other suites? I'm not finding enough reviews about it. Despite the fact that their system mechanic is really good, I'm really wondering about the efficiency of their safety apps. I've trialed others like AVG, Kaspersky, and they haven't found anything more than iolo on my computer. But I still feel the need for re-assurance about safety issues with iolo. I would appreciate any sensible advice...
Reply
Click to view SpiritWind's profile Old Hand 1,293 posts since
Aug 19, 2006
1. Feb 5, 2008 9:13 PM in response to: doublewitt
Re: How does the iolo suite stand amidst the others?
http://forums.pcworld.com/images/emoticons/grin.gif Hi :

I had never HEARD of Iolo Suite prior to your Post . Iolo Technologies is known ONLY for its "System Mechanic" . Their "System Shield 3 Internet Security", "Iolo Antivirus", & "Iolo Personal Firewall" have never been recommended by anyone I know . As to their "Internet Security ( Suite )", we favor the "Layered" Approach on this Forum ; see the "Document" I created at http://forums.pcworld.com/docs/DOC-1141 . IF you are looking for the Best in antivirus protection & you are willing to PAY for it, then "NOD32" from Eset Software is my Choice ; IF a good "FREE" version is acceptable, I recommend Avast Home ( http://www.avast.com ), then AVG Antivirus FREE . For "Pay-for-it" antiSPYWARE/antiTROJAN protection, then "CounterSpy" from Sunbelt Software is my Choice; IF a good "FREE" version is acceptable, my Choice would be the FREE Version of "SUPERAntiSpyware" from http://www.superantispyware.com . Making Firewall recommendations is harder, because the SPECIFIC Version of your Operating System should be known .

IF you are looking for INFO from a good INDEPENDENT Source, I recommend http://www.av-comparatives.org , particularly their Test results for the "Retrospective/Proactive" category ; it is there you will see NOD32 was the runaway "Winner" .


For the BEST in what COUNTS in LIFE : http://www.tacf.org
Click to view piyushsingh's profile Old Hand 2,517 posts since
Jul 21, 2007
3. Feb 7, 2008 5:29 PM in response to: doublewitt
Re: How does the iolo suite stand amidst the others?
i would say that use some other applications for firewall, antivirus. Iolo suite is a perfect tune up utility and it has everything that a great system optimizer utility should have, but its security part arent that good.I had seen 6.0 version on a friends system,also tried the trial version of 7.0 suite some time back - did excellent optimizations.An application cannot excel in all areas, it does great tune ups, so leave the antivirus thing to other apps. meant to do only that part.


Nothing is true , Everything is permitted.
Click to view SpiritWind's profile Old Hand 1,293 posts since
Aug 19, 2006
5. Feb 7, 2008 7:29 PM in response to: doublewitt
Re: How does the iolo suite stand amidst the others?

:D Hi :

Unless you compare the performance of a security program. One really does NOT know IF "It's doing a really good job" . I challenge you to install the FREE Version of "SUPERAntiSpyware" from http://www.superantispyware.com , "Update" it, then run its "Complete Scan" to see IF it detects anything . In another Thread on this Forum, I requested someone to do this and the Result was the "discovery" of some really bad malware . The Poster said he was surprised as he had Lavasoft's Ad-Aware on his computer . You MAY have a similar experience . The concept of centalized data management does NOT apply to computer security for the Best Means of protecting a computer, especially in this increasing creation of malware, which MAY include several trojans AND rootkits which "protect" One another . Most of the people I see asking for help on the Support Sites staffed by experienced, trained, certified, Volunteer "Malware Fighters" require the use of several, specially designed programs to rid their computers of Malware .


For the BEST in what COUNTS in LIFE : http://www.tacf.org
Click to view piyushsingh's profile Old Hand 2,517 posts since
Jul 21, 2007
6. Feb 8, 2008 7:04 AM in response to: doublewitt
Re: How does the iolo suite stand amidst the others?
i have used their trial for 30 days and that is sufficient to judge the capabilities of any program.And if you want to use one complete suite then its fine , atleast you have all in one place and you wont miss any thing. iolo's registry repair is good, so is their junk cleaner and invalid shortcuts remover.They have a memory defragmenter , it shows great jobs on my old system but didnt freed any on my newer(new ram are better designred), defragmenter is good than windows, do deep defragmentation (slow but effective) sometimes.It has a very good system diagnostic tools plus a startup services editor and a power uninstaller that can remove almost any any annoying application.I wasnt impressed by their antivirus, their spython spy removal missed many which avg free edition caught.I think they also have a "duplicate file scanner" - i will avice not to use it , it will list some windows files removing which will land you in trouble, i had to do a system restore after i removed wothout seeing the long list.
i hope that helps. :-)


Nothing is true , Everything is permitted.
Click to view rgreen4's profile Member Moderators 4,307 posts since
Oct 22, 2006
8. Feb 8, 2008 6:41 PM in response to: doublewitt
Re: How does the iolo suite stand amidst the others?

First disconnect your PC from the world (ie: the internet) and run your Iolo scan. Then run the Superantispyware scan, the run Adware SE scan, then run the Iolo scan again. That is four scans.

If Iolo finds spyware on the very last run, you may have to ask where it came from, since it was disconnected from the world.

There have been instances of "false" positives from less than premier anti spy programs.


RGreensig2B
Click to view SpiritWind's profile Old Hand 1,293 posts since
Aug 19, 2006
10. Feb 8, 2008 7:58 PM in response to: doublewitt
Re: How does the iolo suite stand amidst the others?

:D Hi :

The SUPERAntiSpyware Scan Results you Posted were impressive; however, it is RARE that the "File threats detected" are zero . When I run a "Complete scan" of SUPERAntiSpyware I usually get a few "detections" in that "category". I wonder IF it MAY be cause by WHICH "Scanner Options" were selected under the "Scanning Control" Menu !? Which of those "Options" have a checkmark in the "box" ?

By the way, my "Complete scan" usually takes about 35 minutes, with 3 of the "Options" unchecked .


For the BEST in what COUNTS in LIFE : http://www.tacf.org
Click to view mphenterprises's profile Member Moderators 9,120 posts since
Feb 19, 2007
12. Feb 9, 2008 6:30 AM in response to: doublewitt
Re: How does the iolo suite stand amidst the others?
doublewitt wrote:

Currently, I'm using the *latest from iolo technologies for security and system maintenance. So far, I have no real complaints - but - I was just
wondering where does the iolo suite stand compared to others...But I still feel the need for re-assurance about safety issues with iolo.

Hi DoubleWitt and welcome to PCWorld. :-)

Although I personally have not used Iolo Suite or suggest security suites in general, it would appear that you are pretty satisfied with the combination of applications you use. If I may be frank, it also appears that each suggestion we present to you is summarily turned down. If you are content with the way Iolo Suite and System Mechanic protect your computer, there is no need to change or no need for concern.

The vast majority of us within this forum use the layered (or tiered) approach to security. However, it is not for everyone. Personally, I do not rely on reviews or opinions to enable me to choose the right applications, I do as you have, I use the application and make a decision for myself. You are the best judge on how an application works for your computer.


This is my personal Dream PC: http://forums.pcworld.com/blogs/mphenterprises/2007/12/21/my-gift-to-myself
Click to view rgreen4's profile Member Moderators 4,307 posts since
Oct 22, 2006
14. Feb 9, 2008 10:08 AM in response to: doublewitt
Re: How does the iolo suite stand amidst the others?

doublewitt wrote:Yeah, it's not a reason to sit down on the issue. I'm always striving to improve and to ensure that everything goes well.
A wise position to take. The reason that most of the community members do not like tha all in one suites are two fold. 1) A suite may take a particular app that is their strong point - ie: Norton's was noted in the early days for it anti-virus, and add other apps to fill out the suite that are not the strongest. 2) The two best know security suites (Norton's and McAfee) are also noted for taking over and slowing down the PC by it intrusion, and they are notoriously difficult to remove. I get a weekly e-mail newletter put out by Brian Livingston called Windows Secrets. This week they had an article on Symantec's Norton Internet Security and the fact that you cannot completely remove it with Windows Add/Remove and even the Norton Removal Tool leaves behind traces.

This is why some consider Norton as bad as the virus it is supposed to protect us from. And we have to pay for it! http://forums.pcworld.com/servlet/JiveServlet/downloadImage/2310/Emo.hammer.gif


RGreensig2B

Visit other IDG sites: