Quantcast
You are not logged in, click here to log in.
37 Replies Last post: Nov 16, 2008 8:57 AM by noia   1 2 3 Previous Next
Click to view PCWorld's profile PCW News Bot 35,856 posts since
Aug 1, 2007
Reply

Aug 29, 2008 11:20 AM

Critics Question Comcast Broadband Caps

Post your comments for Critics Question Comcast Broadband Caps here
Reply
Click to view kelmerp's profile New Member 1 posts since
Aug 29, 2008
1. Aug 29, 2008 1:06 PM in response to: PCWorld
Re: Critics Question Comcast Broadband Caps
My only concern is whether or not this will affect my Hulu/Netflix InstantWatch addition.
Click to view danthalis's profile New Member 2 posts since
Aug 29, 2008
2. Aug 29, 2008 1:23 PM in response to: PCWorld
Re: Critics Question Comcast Broadband Caps
Comcast has capped all home internet users to 250GB per month. Anyone who uses more will be banned for a year. They say it's because of people clogging the lines. So people with game consoles, vonage, netflix will have to keep a close eye, because comcast isn't providing you any way to keep track of your useage. But you can use their service as much as you want without penalty..... This is not only unfair to it's 'unlimited' use customers, but it hurts future advancement of things like high def streaming video, games, VOIP, and any other technolgy out there that relies on high speed internet.

It will hurt EVERYONE if they are allowed to get away with it.

Comcast customer or not, please take a minute to file a complaint, mention the fact that they aren't helping you keep track on their end and that you can't keep track on yours (because the trackers from goggle don't take vonage, or multiple computers, or game consoles into account)

http://esupport. fcc. gov/complaints. htm

Click to view Shasta's profile New Member 3 posts since
Nov 4, 2006
3. Aug 29, 2008 2:41 PM in response to: PCWorld
Re: Critics Question Comcast Broadband Caps
As a major distributor of Pay for View programming isn't it a little disingenuous for Comcast to place download caps so that you will have to PAY to view their offerings. I don't know many people that have Comcast Internet that don't have Comcast cable as well. Good way to limit competition if you ask me.
Click to view mjd420nova's profile Enthusiast 1,240 posts since
Aug 5, 2006
4. Aug 29, 2008 3:03 PM in response to: PCWorld
Re: Critics Question Comcast Broadband Caps
As a long time Comcast customer, this doesn't really bother me. I have six computers in my home, two wireless laptops, one wireless desktop and three wired desktops, then there is a PS3 and an Xbox 360 that are on wireless but never in use at the same time. I've measured my download usage which usually includes at least two movies, three game downloads for the PS3 or Xbox 360 and a nominal daily usage of four machines for e-mail and bill paying plus online banking. Seldom does it go over 150 GB in a month and then if it does, it's usually by about 5 GB. I'm not worried. I think these throttle controls are mainly aimed to stop or limit the spammers that have proliferated throughout their system. Unlike AOL and Yahoo who will often disable your account is they detect any uploads over a couple days of more that 2 GB, this is not reflected in Comcasts limits to downloads.
Click to view RandomCommentGuy's profile New Member 3 posts since
Jan 17, 2008
5. Aug 29, 2008 3:26 PM in response to: PCWorld
Re: Critics Question Comcast Broadband Caps
"Comcast's terms of service allow the provider to change those terms, and generally focus on acceptable use."

Errr ... until it's challenged. An enforceable contract requires mutually objective manifestation of intent to be bound by the terms of the contract. One cannot assent to terms that are unknown.

Comcast is begging for a juicy class-action lawsuit if they attempt to impose cancellation fees or penalties on customers wishing to take their dollars elsewhere given the new terms of service.

Sometimes its funny to sit back and watch just how short-sighted a company can be.

Hopefully, Verizon, AT&T, and other companies start advertising, "No caps." I think this would yield a competitive advantage for them.
Click to view jinx101's profile New Member 49 posts since
Feb 19, 2008
6. Aug 29, 2008 3:40 PM in response to: PCWorld
Re: Critics Question Comcast Broadband Caps
I have Comcast at home and I'm so annoyed right now. The only other choice I have it AT&T has horrible service. I use my connection for gaming and streaming music that I PAY a subscription for. I was supposed to have an unlimited usage now I have to worry about if I've listened to music too long.

I hate Comcast... why don't I have any better choices? Oh wait, it's because the telecom industry isn't really a free market... they're protected by the government. Comeon FCC, Comcast just threw the gauntlet down, it's your turn to answer.
Click to view danthalis's profile New Member 2 posts since
Aug 29, 2008
7. Aug 29, 2008 4:57 PM in response to: mjd420nova
Re: Critics Question Comcast Broadband Caps

Just out of curiosity, how did you measure you usage? There is no bandwidth meter out there that can track your xbox live, or ps3's home accounts. I guess I should just call comcast's customer service 800 number every hour or so I'm on the internet and ask for a supervisor to see what my usage is.


I mean the is the equivenet of putting up a 15mph speed zone then rippinng out the speedometer in your car, and having to ask the police officer (who may or may not be short on his qouta this month) to let you know if you went past the limit.


Defend Comcast all you want, the truth is that they sold me an 'unlimited' service account, the now will in fact enforced limited. There is no mention anywhere of a limit cap in the contract. 200 users using the internet at peak hours will cause congrestion, no matter how much they are downloading. And finally to offer their loyal and paying customers no other options, no way to check their usage and no means of appeal is pure and utter nonsense.


And again I ask one simple question, why is Comcast's VIOP not taken from your 250GB limit but Vonage's service is?

Click to view 6c1452's profile New Member 2 posts since
Aug 29, 2008
8. Aug 29, 2008 5:01 PM in response to: PCWorld
Re: Critics Question Comcast Broadband Caps
jinx...

Streaming music at 128 kbps 24/7 for a month will use 43 GB. If you're already pushing 200 you can probably cut down on some other area.
Click to view mjd420nova's profile Enthusiast 1,240 posts since
Aug 5, 2006
9. Aug 29, 2008 6:12 PM in response to: danthalis
Re: Critics Question Comcast Broadband Caps
Danthalis: I keep track of how many movies the kids down load, approx 5 to 6 GB each, and the PS3 game down load sizes, plus the Xbox 360 Downloads. The PS3 downloads are between 6 to 7 GB each and the Xbox is usually a little smaller than a movie, near 4 GB. The rest of our usage is pretty small stuff and the music, surfing and bill paying is pretty much negligble, well below 1 GB. I do some music streaming from VH1 and some local radio stations but it's never more than an hours worth each month, which is around 10 MB per minute or close to 600 to 700 MB. When the game machines were new, they downloaded a new game a week, but now that's tapered off to one a month. It's not really too hard to determine your usage, but I keep track because they all run through a router and I do notice when the router gets busy and I check out who's doing what and when.
Click to view scottg2's profile New Member 1 posts since
Aug 30, 2008
10. Aug 30, 2008 1:05 AM in response to: PCWorld
Re: Critics Question Comcast Broadband Caps
This is news Scumcast booted me off their system 4 years ago for bandwidth overages. At least now they'll tell you what the limit is couldn't get that out of them back then. 1st a bandwidth ticket, then they cut u off till u call them then they give u the boot.
Click to view ogman's profile New Member 45 posts since
Feb 7, 2007
11. Aug 30, 2008 2:55 AM in response to: PCWorld
Re: Critics Question Comcast Broadband Caps
This is an anti-trust lawsuit just waiting to be filed. Comcast owns and offers high-bandwidth services, both movies and VoIP. I'm willing to bet that they will not count consumption of those branded services against the cap. They do not clarify which services will be counted against the cap. They also limit usage without providing any legitimate monitoring tools for the consumer to track usage. Finally, it is very possible that they are breaching contracts with consumers by capping the service in the first place. Comcast can only get away with this because they hold monopoly or near monopoly status in many areas in which they operate.

All Comcast customers should immediately write to Congress and the FCC, or look into hiring an attorney to begin legal proceedings against Comcast. If you wish to contact Congress, the website Congress.org is an excellent resource.
Click to view dcolley's profile New Member 5 posts since
Jul 26, 2008
12. Aug 30, 2008 10:08 AM in response to: PCWorld
Re: Critics Question Comcast Broadband Caps
Comcast users should switch to another ISP. They do not have a bandwidth problem. They simply want to figure out more ways to get their greedy hands on their customers money.
Click to view egodraconis's profile New Member 4 posts since
Aug 28, 2008
13. Aug 30, 2008 11:00 AM in response to: PCWorld
Re: Critics Question Comcast Broadband Caps
dcolley, switching is easier said than done. Many consumers do not have options when it comes to choosing another high speed internet provider. Also, many of these other choices lie about the bandwidth they provide. My family tested Qwest's DSL, and it only reached 1/4 of the promised download speed so we canceled service with them. We need truth in advertising from broadband providers. If I sold a car promising that it could reach speeds of 150MPH but in fact it only traveled at 50MPH, then I would be in jail. Why do we allow these broadband providers to break obvious laws regarding advertising without consequences? Lastly, state and federal regulatory agencies will not permit Comcast to move forward with this plan without presenting customer with a clear and accurate meter on Comcast's website indicating how much bandwidth is being used. It would be like your cell phone provider not allowing you to see how many minutes you've used each month, then cut your service off when you've used up your allotted plan minutes.
Click to view saumaun's profile New Member 9 posts since
Feb 11, 2008
14. Aug 30, 2008 1:13 PM in response to: PCWorld
Re: Critics Question Comcast Broadband Caps
egodraconis is RIGHT ON THE MONEY with the phone usage remark. We aren't armed with the tools to check our bandwith.

Visit other IDG sites: